EICR or PAT testing: which assessment answers your question?
An EICR concerns the fixed electrical installation; appliance inspection and testing concerns equipment connected to it. One does not replace the other. Start with the item or risk you need assessed, then ask a competent provider to define the appropriate scope rather than booking whichever certificate name sounds familiar.
Loyal Plumbers · Updated
Discuss an EICR enquiryDescribe the question before choosing a test
A damaged kettle lead, an unexplained circuit trip and a landlord’s request for a condition report are different enquiries. Write down what has happened, where it happened and whether a particular item was involved. If equipment is damaged or suspected unsafe, stop using it and seek competent advice; a future scheduled inspection is not a reason to continue using a faulty item.
The booking conversation should distinguish a known fault from routine condition assessment. An EICR may identify a concern that needs separate fault-finding, while an appliance test does not diagnose every reason a circuit trips. Tell the provider whether your priority is a report, a particular fault or a maintenance programme. That prevents a visit being organised around the wrong deliverable.
Map the fixed installation and connected equipment
Think in terms of the supply arrangement and the things that use it. Consumer units, circuits and fixed wiring belong to the installation question. A desk lamp or vacuum cleaner is an equipment question. Permanently connected equipment can complicate the boundary, so ask how items such as a built-in appliance or hard-wired heater will be treated.
Do not disconnect fixed equipment to make it available for a test yourself. List its location, purpose and connection type if known, and let the competent provider explain the access needed. In a flat, distinguish the dwelling’s installation from communal areas managed by someone else. A certificate for the building’s shared system is not automatically an assessment of everything inside your home.
Understand what an appliance inspection contributes
HSE describes appliance assessment as involving visual examination and, where appropriate, testing. Some defects are visible while others need tests; the two activities have different value. A sticker should not be treated as a substitute for a sensible maintenance arrangement or for taking new damage seriously after the inspection date.
For a household or small workplace inventory, identify equipment by location and a recognisable description. Where several identical items exist, a stable reference helps connect a result to the correct item. Ask what happens when something cannot be accessed or is found defective. The useful record tells you what was assessed and what action remains, rather than merely counting labels applied during a visit.
Avoid the automatic annual-testing assumption
HSE’s guidance does not impose a universal annual PAT requirement under the Electricity at Work Regulations. The appropriate approach depends on equipment, use and environment. Contractual requirements or a particular setting may add their own expectations, so check the actual requirement instead of repeating a rule heard elsewhere.
A property manager should be able to explain why the chosen maintenance arrangement suits the equipment. Items moved frequently or exposed to damage may need different attention from protected equipment in a stable location. This is a risk-based decision for someone competent, not a reason to abandon checks altogether. Ask for a recommendation with a rationale and a route for reporting damage between planned visits.
Keep EICR findings and appliance results separate
An EICR should identify its installation extent and any limitations. Appliance records should identify the equipment assessed. Store both where relevant, but do not merge them into one ambiguous statement that everything electrical has passed. A satisfactory finding in one category does not cancel a defect in the other.
If a report identifies a socket problem and an appliance assessment identifies a damaged plug, each needs the appropriate response. Where the cause is uncertain, ask the provider to explain what additional investigation would distinguish an equipment fault from an installation fault. Avoid repeatedly resetting protective devices or trying the suspect item at different outlets as a substitute for competent diagnosis.
Plan access and interruption around the right activity
For fixed wiring assessment, discuss distribution boards, room access and the effects of switching circuits off. For appliance assessment, discuss which equipment will be available, whether it can be unplugged safely and which items are in use at particular times. A shared list is especially useful when the booking person will not be present.
Explain any critical equipment and agree suitable arrangements with the responsible people before attendance. Do not assume that an inspector can interrupt every supply without notice. Access restrictions can change what is achievable and what the final record says. Resolving them beforehand usually produces a more useful assessment than discovering that half the intended scope cannot be reached on the day.
Compare quotations by deliverables
Ask a provider to identify the assessment, scope, exclusions, reporting and treatment of further work. An appliance count and an installation inspection are not comparable units of work. A low figure is difficult to evaluate if the list omits fixed equipment, inaccessible rooms or documentation you actually need.
Ask whether remedial work is included or separately authorised and what evidence will be supplied when a fault is corrected. For a tenancy or business requirement, show the exact wording of the request. The provider can then explain whether the proposed assessment answers it. Do not ask for a certificate name alone and expect the person attending to infer your legal, contractual and practical requirements.
Make an enquiry that routes to the right help
For an EICR enquiry with Loyal Plumbers, provide the property details, reason for the assessment, existing report if available and known access restrictions. If your question is specifically about appliance testing, say so and confirm the required service with the provider before booking. This guide does not imply that every electrical assessment is included in an EICR appointment.
Keep the eventual report, equipment list and follow-up actions distinct but easy to find. Review the arrangements when use changes, equipment is added or a problem is reported. The objective is to know which installation or item has been assessed and what remains to be done. A folder full of certificates is less useful if no one can connect them to the actual property and equipment.
Common questions
- Can PAT testing replace an EICR?
- No. Appliance assessment and fixed installation condition reporting address different scopes. Identify which one your concern or requirement relates to; in some settings both may be relevant.
- Must every appliance be tested every year?
- HSE does not prescribe a universal annual PAT interval. A competent maintenance approach considers equipment, use and environment, alongside any applicable contractual or setting-specific requirements.
- Is a hard-wired appliance automatically covered by an EICR?
- Do not assume that. Ask the provider to define the boundary between the installation and equipment assessment and the access needed for that particular appliance.
Sources and further reading
Need help with this in London?
Emergency repairs, investigations and planned installations across London and inside the M25. Tell us what you need so we can agree the next step.
Discuss your job